Can you name this song?
Classical
Spread this tune!
Proposals
Comments
RECENT ACTIVITIES
-
Hillayse posted 3min agonew sample in Other
-
Lapizza edited 5min agoSample was edited
-
CeSaRpErEZ posted 6min agonew sample in Other
-
Lapizza edited 7min agoSample was edited
-
Lapizza edited 9min agoSample was edited
-
Lapizza posted 9min agonew sample in Pop
-
1
FluidtyQueen answered 13min agoPET3RPUNX - All The Things She Said (HYPERTECHNO REMIX)
-
AlexSwag24 commented 14min ago
Yup, this is AI.
Might be ai?
-
1
FluidtyQueen answered 15min agoPET3RPUNX - Mute (m) 2:21 / 3:02 All The Things She Said (HYPERTECHNO REMIX)
-
Superawesome posted 16min agonew sample in Soul, Funk, Rap
julombie
By accessing the catalog I meant finding the actual publication by Kobylańska, be it in pdf or a physical copy, to read the commentary and likely see the fascimile of the manuscript.
Luckily, I found the manuscript elsewhere. I was hoping they would be complete pieces, but in fact these are only two short sketches.
http://kolekcja.nifc.pl/object-m-202
That manuscript was supposedly sent by George Sand along with her letter to Stefan Witwicki. The letter in question was resent several times and owned by different people.
Zygmunt Mycielski published the letters (translated into Polish) and the sheet music of the sketch in the Polish magazine Muzyka (issue R.7 nr1 from 20 January 1930).
Here's the issue of the magazine. See the musical fragment on page 12.
https://www.wbc.poznan.pl/dlibra/publication/266266/edition/234743/content
After reading the letters, it seems neither Sand nor Witwicki indicated that there was any sheet music attached. It was Karolina Mężeńska (the granddaughter) who wrote that the manuscript had been put into the envelope by Sand.
2 days ago
maau34w
What do you mean by accessing the catalog to be more exact?
3 days ago
maau34w
It is well known that this is a spurious work, but where do these incipits come from?
3 days ago
krillbeats
*F major
4 days ago
krillbeats
In the site it says: These pieces are possibly spurious.
Apart from that, i searched chopins works: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_compositions_by_Fr%C3%A9d%C3%A9ric_Chopin_by_genre
I listened to the only prelude in d major and it's incorrect. Plus i listened to the majority of his preludes and didnt find nothing, so yeah, maybe its an illegitimate composition
4 days ago
julombie
Since It's taken from the catalog of Chopin's works by Krystyna Kobylańska, maybe we would get more info if we could access the catalog?
PL name: Rękopisy utworów Chopina: katalog
DE name: Frédéric Chopin: Thematisch-bibliographisches Werkverzeichnis
6 days ago
maau34w
https://www.pianolibrary.org/composers/chopin/prelude-andantino-kk-anh1a2-anh1a3/#1
7 days ago